Diesel Generators vs Petrol Generators

Also see articles on:
- How does a Generator Work?
- Generators Buyer's Guide
- How to Drain a Generator of Fuel

While generators are a great way to get power on the move, to a remote location or even as a backup if you have a power cut, you need to make sure you have the right one. Deciding whether to get a petrol or diesel generator is one of the first parts of the process. There are benefits to both fuel types to consider so let's have a look at them both and help you make an informed decision.

How Generators Work

In short, generators convert fuel to kinetic energy and then into electricity. Most generators built for consumers, workshops and homes will use petrol or diesel to do this. Generators will usually use an internal combustion engine to create the movement/kinetic energy.

If you'd like to find out more about how a generator works read our guide.

Performance and Efficiency

Efficiency and performance are a big factor in your decision process. You don't want to be spending too much money on fuel for limited output and performance.

If efficiency is your main priority, a diesel generator is likely to be your best bet. Diesel generators generally have the upper hand when it comes to fuel efficiency. It'll mean longer running times and fewer stops to refuel when compared to a petrol generator.

However, if you're in need of high power outputs quickly, petrol may be a better option. Petrol generators are great for short-term, high-demand use but will burn through the fuel faster than a diesel generator.

Cost Considerations

The initial cost and ongoing maintenance is another big part of helping you decide which fuel type to choose.

The purchase cost of a diesel generator is often a little higher than that of a petrol generator. What's more, diesel is usually a little more expensive than petrol per litre. However, the benefit to this is that they tend to have a lower operational cost in the long run due to the fuel efficiency of diesel.

Maintenance costs are up for debate and will fall to personal preference. However, diesel generators are recommended to have more frequent services. This is because they tend to have slightly more complex systems but they do tend to have a longer lifespan on average if well looked after when compared to petrol generators.

Environmental Impact

Environmental impact can be a deciding factor, and as you'd expect diesel generators do have a reputation for higher emissions as opposed to petrol. However, modern diesel generators are designed to fall within strict emission standards and as such, they can be more environmentally friendly than older models. So if you'd like to have less of an impact overall on the environment, a petrol generator is the better choice.

The noise level also falls under the impact on the environment. Petrol generators are often quieter than their diesel counterparts. With that in mind, it may be a better choice for noise-sensitive areas or in workshops.

Applications and Usability

If you're looking for generators that will be used in a large-scale commercial setting, diesel-powered generators are often favoured. This is because they tend to offer better fuel efficiency which makes them ideal for settings like construction for example.

Petrol generators, on the other hand, are more commonly used in residential settings and for recreational purposes. Their lower initial cost and ease of use make them a popular choice for home backup power, camping trips, and outdoor events.

Pros and Cons of Diesel Generators

Advantages:

• Fuel efficiency is a bit better than petrol
• They tend to be a bit more durable
• You can expect a higher power output

Disadvantages:

• Tent to cost more to purchase
• Diesel generators are generally louder
• You may find you need to perform more regular maintenance

Pros and Cons of Petrol Generators

Advantages:

• A lower purchase price generally
• Usually produces less noise
• Less maintenance is required compared to diesel generators

Disadvantages:

• Less efficient than diesel engines
• Shorter lifespan and is less durable under continuous heavy use
• A lower power output which isn't ideal for prolonged use

Choosing the Right Generator for Your Needs

Take into consideration the period of use and the location in which the generator will be used, whether it's a diesel or a petrol generator. Diesel generators are efficient for long-lasting, heavy usage due to their durability and fuel efficiency. This makes them great for construction sites, and in remote areas.

A petrol generator may fit short-period or less-demanding use. Petrol generators are cheaper and tend to be more portable which makes them ideal as a backup for home use, camping, or even outdoor events and parties. They are relatively quieter when it comes to respecting residential areas.

The other, and probably more important factor is the factor of cost. Diesel generators might be more expensive to purchase, but in effect, they turn out to be low running costs since the fuel they use is low-cost diesel fuel. Diesel generators will usually have a longer lifespan, while petrol generators have low initial investment costs. However, in the long run, petrol generators can be expensive. Since they consume more fuel, you will have to refuel them more often.

The environmental impact of diesel generators means higher emissions, although diesel generators have significantly improved their emission levels. This means that new models are often a great choice.

Noise is essential if you live in a residential area. Running a diesel generator may be quite loud, which may not be ideal if you have close neighbours or need to keep the generator running for extended periods of time. Petrol generators are quieter and more appropriate for noise-sensitive surroundings.

Conclusion

Both diesel and petrol generators have their unique advantages and disadvantages. Diesel generators offer efficiency, durability, and higher power output, making them ideal for industrial and long-term use. Petrol generators, on the other hand, are cost-effective, quieter, and easier to maintain, perfect for residential and short-term applications. Assess your specific needs, budget, and environmental considerations to choose the right generator for your situation.

By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each type, you can make a well-informed decision that ensures reliable power whenever you need it.